American Idol Group 1 (Spoiler Added)

cyndicyndi Registered Users Posts: 3,341
WOW! I'm really impressed, these first 3 can really sing! I hope the rest of the of the group is just as good! The little 16 year old who opened the show is adorable!
Failed to load the poll.
Failed to load the poll.
I think that I deceive genius.:happy10:


  • SpringcurlSpringcurl Registered Users Posts: 8,002
    I'm voting for several people, so I couldn't use your poll.

    I love Fantasia the best of everybody. Second was Diana. Those are my top two, anyway.

    Obamacare is not a blueprint for socialism. You're thinking of the New Testament. ~~ John Fugelsang

  • marielle448marielle448 Registered Users Posts: 1,823
    I voted as follows:

    1. Diana - sounds like Taylor Dane or Anastasia, awesome performance

    5. Erskin - smooth

    6. Jennifer - okay performance, awesome potential

    8. Fantasia - she's like a female Elvis
  • cyndicyndi Registered Users Posts: 3,341
    Just vote for your top pick...let's see if the NC top two are the same as America's top two!
    I think that I deceive genius.:happy10:
  • munchkinmunchkin Registered Users Posts: 2,909 Curl Connoisseur
    Your poll wouldn't let me vote for some reason. I voted for Diana three times hoping she gets one of the two spots. BUT, I also voted for Fantasia because I think she absolutely was the best. Besides having the best voices, they both seemed so comfortable on stage.

    This group as a whole put a lot of the top 10 from last year to shame.

    OK, your poll did let me vote after I posted the above.
  • MichelleMichelle Administrator Administrators Posts: 742 Administrator
    I agree with Munchkin. The caliber of singing is so much better this time. I think Fantasia is amazing. She's got such a unique sound a a cool attitude. Diana is incredible too, especially for someone so young. I think Marque is gorgeous and has real stage presence. I heard Paula say that the girls this time are incredible.

    I'm already addicted.

  • CGNYCCGNYC Registered Users Posts: 4,938 Curl Connoisseur
    I thought all of the guys were weak. I wasn't wild about smiley - she has a nice voice but watching her is dull. I also didn't like the girl who sang "Crazy." Five thousand people have sung that song that exact same way, does there need to be another? Do something different. And cheerleader - did we learn nothing from the Frim Fram Sauce? Jazz is great, but on AI it's just weird.

    I'm all about Jennifer and then Fantasia.

    I wish they would pick more interesting or exciting or less blah songs. I get bored pretty easily.
  • Kelly!Kelly! Registered Users Posts: 21
    I LOVE LOVE LOVE Fantasia! Such a different sound. It's sorta Macy Gray-ish, but much stronger. It's like Patti Labelle meets Macy Gray. I love it and I love her personality. Hopefully America feels the same way.

    I also like Jennifer (can't think of her last name). Such a pretty girl with a powerful voice. I don't think she chose a song, though, that really showcased what she can do without going over the top.

    The other girls .... blah.

    The guys... My aunt knows Erskine. He has a nice voice but comes across very blah in personality, though. I think he lacks a certain kind of charisma that he needs to catch people's eye.

    The one really cute guy has a nice rock voice. Wonder if there's a spot in Creed for him....

    I think Fantasia and Jennifer will be chosen tomorrow. Fantasia definitely, and if Jennifer isn't chosen, I believe she'll be a wild card pick.
    "Love yourselves, nurture your students and make this world a better place by your having been part of it." --J. Howland
  • CanItBeChristineCanItBeChristine Registered Users Posts: 6,343
    I really liked Katie tonight...she's so cute and I loved her performance, but that's the kind of music that I like, so she's probably not right for the show.

    Erskin (sp?) was great and looked gorgeous and seems sweet. I like his smile.

    I LOVED Matthew last week, and thought he was cute and entertaining this week...I like the sound of his voice.
  • BritBrit Registered Users Posts: 4
    Marque is gorgeous and i love his voice. i even loved him when he did his audition.

    I don't understand the Fantasia thing. I can hear that she does sound a little like Macy Gray (who I do like), but I was just not impressed with her. What is with that little bouncing thing she does while singing? I do agree that she is unique and seems to have a nice personality, but I just can't stand her stage presence and her voice didn't wow me.

    Oh, the first girl, the 16 year old, she is a great singer and performer. i definitely see her making it big at some point with or without AI.
    If we don't watch out good, all we beads just gon' slide off we string. . .
  • MizK9MizK9 Registered Users Posts: 16
    Fantasia, is incredible! Her voice really stood out (unique & powerful)–and a personality to match. Diana is also great for a 16 year old. Marque is adorable & a voice to match.

    I agree with the others…these first 8 are much better than last years contestants.

    Bring it on!
  • curlyKarcurlyKar Registered Users Posts: 4
    I voted for a couple people as well so I couldn't use your poll. I think all of them are really talented. Diana was awesome. I enjoyed Katie's performance as well. I like Matthew. His singing wasn't really strong last night but he definetely has a charisma about him and great stage presence. Plus he's adorable! :D
    3B Jersey Girl with brunette curls just past shoulders

    "Tomorrow is always fresh..with no mistakes in it"- Anne Of Green Gables
    "Hiccups in life aren't necessarily a bad thing..."
  • munchkinmunchkin Registered Users Posts: 2,909 Curl Connoisseur
    Our little poll is showing Fantasia and Diana winning (which is who I personally think it should be). Surprisingly, I was on another site (think maybe msn or msnbc... can't remember) and Fantasia and Katie were winning with Diana and Jennifer (I believe) following.

    I sure hope if Diana doesn't make it that she gets in as a wild card.
  • cyndicyndi Registered Users Posts: 3,341
    Ok....we'll see if it's Diana and Fantacia!!
    I think that I deceive genius.:happy10:
  • cyndicyndi Registered Users Posts: 3,341
    Poor erskine didn't get any votes!
    I think that I deceive genius.:happy10:
  • cyndicyndi Registered Users Posts: 3,341
    Damn, we're! :lol:

    Diana and Fantasia win the spots!
    I think that I deceive genius.:happy10:

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file