Article: Is Pilates bad for your back?

CurlyBritChickCurlyBritChick Posts: 218Registered Users
Interesting article in today's newspaper about the benefits of Pilates & Yoga:
Is Pilates bad for your back?

Experts are now asking whether Pilates is doing more harm than good to back pain sufferers

Pilates has fast become the fitness craze of the Noughties.

Favoured by celebrities and sports people alike, it is widely considered the best form of exercise for improving back pain and poor posture.

But some experts are now casting doubt over its ability to relieve back problems.

Indeed, they suggest that many who take it up might actually do themselves more harm than good.

Pilates is named after its founder, Joseph Pilates, a German-born sportsman who devised the exercise method 75 years ago, initially to improve strength.

He set up a fitness studio in New York at an address he shared with the New York City Ballet.

Word spread about his workout and Pilates was soon teaching actors and athletes.

Today, it is estimated that 25million people now take regular Pilates classes in the US and more than one million do the same in the UK — its celebrity fans include Madonna, Sigourney Weaver and Liz Hurley.

Its attraction is that it promises a means of staying toned and slim with good posture.

Crucially, participants are taught how to target a muscle called the transversus abdominus, positioned deep in the abdominal area.

This they do by drawing in their navel to the spine and lifting the pelvic floor.

But according to Stuart McGill, a professor of spine biomechanics and chair of the kinesiology department at the University of Waterloo in Ontario, it is this concept of "drawing in" that is the problem.

He and his colleagues have found that strengthening this "core" muscle often worsens back pain.

It's generally assumed that when you pull in this muscle, the torso temporarily acts like a corset, protecting the lower back, and that if the muscle is used often enough, it will eventually work on its own.

But by measuring how different loads and forces affect the way the spine functions, McGill found that the transversus abdominus muscle does not play as pivotal a role in protecting the back as was once thought.

"If you hollow in, you bring the muscles closer to the spine and you reduce the stability of the back," McGill says. "Try rising from a chair with a hollowed-out stomach. Not only are you weak, it is very difficult."

More than one-third of the UK population (17.3million people) have experienced back problems for more than one day in the past 12 months, according to the charity BackCare.

More than half have endured it for between a month and a year, and for six out of ten people the pain is severe enough to disrupt everyday activities at least once in their lives.

Exercise programmes such as Pilates that promise to prevent or eliminate the dull, persistent ache seem the ideal solution. But they can be a recipe for disaster.

"I have seen many people who have done their backs serious harm through Pilates,’ says Fiona Troup, a physiotherapist and qualified Pilates instructor at the Sports & Spinal Clinic, Harley Street.

"Unless it is tailored to an individual and taught correctly according to their back diagnosis, it can cause injury."

The drawing in of core muscles became a fitness mantra ten years ago when Australian researchers found that people with lower back pain used the muscle less when they did various physical tasks.

The researchers recommended that physiotherapists teach patients how to contract both the transversus abdominus muscle and another — the multifidus — in the lower back.

But the lead researcher, Professor Carolyn Richardson of the University of Queensland's department of physiotherapy, has recently admitted she was concerned that the fitness industry had made the technique as popular as conventional stretching and warming-up exercises.

"I've found that for the fitness industry, it's a poor instruction that is often misinterpreted or carried out badly," she now says.

"It is easily done incorrectly by people mistakenly holding their breath or sucking in so far that they round their back."

As a result, the correct muscles aren't targeted and, over time, the back becomes more vulnerable than before.

Claire Small, a spokesperson for the Chartered Society of Physiotherapy shares the growing concerns about Pilates and other exercise classes that claim to prevent back pain.

"In some people, attempting to engage the core muscles can trigger a reaction that makes their condition deteriorate," she says.

"In theory, all the core, abdominal and pelvic muscles should contract simultaneously so that they inflate like a balloon inside the abdominal cavity, but incorrect technique can cause the pelvic muscles to descend which is bad news as it potentially weakening for the back."

For anyone with back pain, the consequences can be dire and "they wonder why they are putting in so much effort at Pilates but feeling worse", says Small.

Even among those who do perform the core contraction correctly, the benefits are doubtful. Professor Shirley Sahrmann, a physical therapist at the Washington University School of Medicine found that, no matter how many times the movement is repeated, it does not become second nature and therefore will not provide constant back support.

And because back pain has so many different causes, attempting to strengthen the core muscles might be entirely the wrong remedy for some.

As Small explains: "If your back problems are caused by stiff hips — a common cause — then doing Pilates will not help to improve it."

It is not just Pilates that is coming under fire from experts. Yoga, another exercise often touted as back-friendly, can also be harmful.

Matt Todman, consultant physiotherapist at the Sports & Spinal Clinic, Harley Street, says that the ancient exercise form "is generally not good for back pain and a lot of its postures can compound the problem by loading pressure on the back".

Last year, an American study found that while a gentle yoga class seemed a better alternative to general exercise or following a self-help book for back pain, some more vigorous types of yoga and classes led by poorly qualified instructors potentially made back problems worse.

But experts do concede that for some people in some instances, Pilates can be helpful in back pain relief.

"But it is never going to be enough on its own," says Troup. "A strong back means a combination of strong muscles in the buttocks, spinal area and shoulders not just a well-developed core area."

If you are suffering from back pain it is important to consult your doctor.

What to do if you're in pain

Keep moving. While people with back pain need to be careful about the type and amount of exercise they do, experts agree that some activity is better than none.

For many years the advice for back pain was bed rest, but in 1996 the Royal College of General Practitioners changed its guidelines and patients are now meant to be encouraged to keep active — using pain relief if necessary.

However, the new guidelines remain unheeded by many in the medical profession.

"A lot of people are still told to lie down until they feel a bit better, despite the fact that movement or active management is known to be far more effective," says Nia Taylor of the charity BackCare.

A major study on non-surgical treatments for back pain found that patients obtain as much benefit from an intense programme of exercise therapy as from spinal surgery.

Those who followed a tailored two-hour daily exercise regime which included activities such as step-ups, walking on a treadmill, and cycling, made huge progress over just three weeks.

However, specific back exercises might be bad news. American researchers have found that back exercises (twists and stretches) generally increased the risk of pain and suffering over time.

If you have back pain and want to start an exercise regime, first consult a physiotherapist.
Type 3b, Highlighted, Past Shoulders, Fine Texture, but very dense.


  • miacurlmiacurl Posts: 332Registered Users
    Just as I have suspected for a long time. I also think yoga is over-rated for back pain. Depends on the back problem and depends on the yoga or pilates move/exercise. Some things worsen it and some things help it.

    I find hip opening and stretching along with back and abdominal exercises are the best to help keep me free of back pain. Also, basic body mechanics. Stretching hamstrings, shoulders, traps, posture exercises, all great for back care.
    2C/3A auburn hair.
    between shoulders and BSL
  • godgivenpermgodgivenperm Posts: 678Registered Users
    That was very interesting to me. I have a bad lower back and I do stay away from Pilates because the moves are uncomfortable for me and make my back hurt more.

    Like miacurl, I too find that gentle stretching overall helps keep me as pain free as I can be (I always have some).
    No more PJ tendencies. Tigi Curls Rock Curl Amplifier is the best thing to make my curls rock all day! Next best are KCCC and Re:Coil +HE TT Gel.

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file