I have naturally long, curly lashes. I wish they were a tad thicker; but for some reason, volumizing formulas dont do well on me. I have tried. The one exception is l'oreal's Voluminous, but for some reason I am not crazy about it. I would like to find a great drug store mascara, one that is not waterproof (I dont like having to use an eye makeup remover). Any suggestions? Ohm BTW, my eyes are brownish hazel, so I can wear black or violet.